Monday, 26 November 2012

Christians Don't Like Christian Music



I have thought long and hard about if I should write this next entry. It is a subject that I am very passionate about, but also one that a lot of other people are too. Due to the nature of it, there are a million different view points on the matter and therefore disagreements seem to be very common. However, I need to put this out there, it is driving me a little crazy just swimming around in my head. I haven't got the definitive answer to what I am going to present, I think that is something that will come out of discussion in the wider church community. I am not attacking people with this post, I am just asking all of us to look into the mirror and address what I raise.

So, here goes....

Christians do not like Christian music.

Now, I am fully aware that such a statement is a sweeping generalization. There are Christians, both those who are involved in worship teams and those who are not, who listen to Christian music at times other than whilst at church.  If they didn't, then no Christian artist would ever realize anything, because it would be pointless (plus I have even seen the proof in the wild... a christian with some worship albums in their CD collection.. shock horror).

You may think that what I am saying in downright wrong, even offencive, but please hear my logical reasoning for what I say.

Most of us like music, right? If you asked most Christians the straight forward question 'Do you like music?', I would be extremely surprised if the the vast majority didn't answer 'yes'. Further to this, Christians buy CDs, right (or pay to download music)? I can't remember a time I have been in someones house and not seen a CD collection, or an itunes library (being how I am with music, I am always very keen to see what people have in their collection.. you have been warned :). So, If Christians liked Christian music.... it should be in the charts right? Well, it isn't. Oh, so why?

About 6% of the uk population attend church regularly. By my callcalations, this is about 3,780,000 people. That is a lot of people! Now, I understand that not all of those people are Christians, that those figures are debateable etc etc... but even if you half that figure, it is still a lot of people.

Now, to put this in context, we need to look at how many albums you would have to sell to top the album charts here in the UK. Well, Rihanna's recent album, Talk That Talk reached No. 1 in August by selling a mere 9,578 copies in a week (physical and digital sales combined). That was a particularly slow sales week, but even in a good sales week, Mumford and Sons (Not a Christian band before anyone suggests it) only had to sell 159,000 copies to top the charts. That really isn't very many, is it?

Awareness is not the issue here. In this world of social media, Christian artists make it very clear when they are releasing a new album. Their status updates are very keen to let us know when this is the case. They may not have the same marketing budgets that a lot of the purely secular artist do, but that is certainly not the reason that they are not entering the charts. The reason is that Christians are not buying the music. It is that simple!

This is, in my view, very troubling. Why wouldn't someone want to listen to worship/Christian music at a time other than a Sunday morning? Surely you would want to worship through out the week (I appreciate that music is not the only form of worship btw).

For years we have been saying that our congregations want a certain type of music. We often aim for the middle ground, or imitate what we think is popular with people (sometimes about two years too late...come on, you know its true). We hold huge conferences where thousands of people worship together. Worshiping God is more than just liking the music, of course it is, but I just can't understand why Christian artists aren't regularly in the charts. There is a huge disconnect with the music that Christian artists are producing and what Christians actually want to listen to.

As I said, I don't have the answers. I do think that those in the the world of Christian music really need to examine this disconnect that they have with their audience. I have so many conversations with people about music, so often I hear Christians say 'I'm not really into Christian music'. These people love God, love music.... they really want to love christian music!!! So, what exactly are we waiting for? Why are we scared to step away from the middle ground? 

Really, if I am missing something here, please tell me. I want this addressed, not brushed under the carpet. I want to talk about the elephant in the room! I want, more than anything, for someone to listen to Radio One and for them to be able to hear a fantastic, cutting edge song about how much God loves them or why we love Him so much. Wow, how amazing would that be? Thing is.... it really is not a hard thing to achieve!

No comments:

Post a Comment